IT Support - Google Drive vs Box: Which cloud storage is best for you?

The UMD Division of Information Technology offers an array of data storage options for current students, faculty, and staff. The following comparison of Google Drive and Box will help you decide which service will best meet your data storage needs.

What are Drive and Box?

Google Drive is an online storage service that allows you to store, share, and collaborate on your files. Drive is also integrated with Google apps such as Docs, Sheets, and Slides, enabling you to create, store, and share documents in a variety of file formats.

Google Shared Drives are also available. Shared Drives are not tied to individual user accounts and allow you to manage large collections of files and folders separately from individual Drives. To learn more about Drive, visit the Google Drive. To learn more about Shared Drives, view the Google Shared Drives Guide.

Box is a cloud-based storage and collaboration system that offers a Web interface for uploading, downloading, sharing, and discussing files. Box is designed to work on desktop and mobile devices, giving you access to your files from just about anywhere. To learn more about Box, visit UMD Box Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ).

Top

What features do Box and Drive offer?

Both services offer:

Online viewing for select file types
Integrated communication and collaboration tools
File and folder access and permissions management
Downloadable sync tools for use with Macs, PCs, and iOS and Android mobile devices
Built-in search engines

However, each offers unique features that may be valuable for different data storage purposes. The following feature breakdown can be helpful when deciding which storage service to use:

Top

Feature breakdown

	Box	Drive
Storage capacity	Default Allocations: 500 GB for Individuals; 1 TB for Box Group Accounts	Faculty and staff: 256 GB Current students: 256 GB Alumni accounts: 15 GB
Accepted File Types	Accepted File Types in Box	Accepted File Types in Google Drive
Group Accounts	Available upon Request	Available via Shared Drives or Google Shared Accounts
Integrated Applications	Box Drive (Windows, Macintosh) Box for Outlook Box for Office Box for Android Devices Box for Android Tablet Box for iPad Box for iPhone Box for TouchPad Box for SimpleShare Box for E-mail Box for Webdocs Box for XML Viewer	Google Apps, including: Gmail (email) Calendar (meetings, appointments, and reminders) Groups (mailing lists and collaborative email) Docs (word processing) Sheets (spreadsheets) Forms (web-based forms) Slides (presentations) Hangouts (chat and video)
Microsoft Office Suite Integration	Export and Import Microsoft Office Online and Desktop compatible	Export and Import
Mobile Device Access	Apps available for: Android iOS	Apps available for: Android iOS
Allowed Data Types	Low (Level 1) data includes: - Data made freely available by public sources - Published data - Educational data - Initial and intermediate Research Data Moderate (Level 2) data includes: - Non-PII student records - Personnel records High (Level 3) data includes: - Personally Identifiable Information (PII) as defined in Maryland Code, Commercial Law § 14-3501 - Identifiable data elements that contain sensitive health information that are not otherwise subject to HIPAA	Low (Level 1) data includes: - Data made freely available by public sources - Published data - Educational data - Initial and intermediate Research Data Moderate (Level 2) data includes: - Non-PII student records - Personnel records
Prohibited Data Types	Credit Card or Payment Card Industry (PCI) Protected health information governed by HIPAA Federal Information Security Management Act (FISMA) Data Federal Tax Information Student Loan Application Information (GLBA)	Credit Card or Payment Card Industry (PCI) Federal Information Security Management Act (FISMA) Data Federal Tax Information Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act(GLBA) Social Security Numbers US Export Controlled Data Protected health information governed by HIPAA

Top

Data classification: Will my data be safe?

Both Google Drive and Box have adequate security controls in place to properly secure the approved data types. Each application provides additional administrative controls that maybe utilized to further secure data and limit its sharing.

Online storage of data is subject to the UMD Data Classification Standard. Review these standards to learn what data types (Low (Level 1) , Moderate (Level 2) , or High (Level 3) applies to your data.

Google Drive can be used to store Low (Level 1) and Moderate (Level 2) data types.
Box can be used to store Low (Level 1), Moderate (Level 2) and High (Level 3) data types.

BOX		DRIVE
For a storage amount of a high amount of High (Level 3) risk data with a need for limited communication and collaboration.		For storage of Low (Level 1) and Moderate (Level 2) risk data with a need for extensive, flexible collaboration.

Have additional questions?

Contact IT Compliance at it-compliance@umd.edu for additional information about storing UMD data.

Top

IT Service Desk

Find solutions and report issues